Bright Data alternatives
Best Bright Data Alternatives: 5 Proxy and SERP APIs (2026)
5 Bright Data alternatives tested on parsed Google SERPs and cost per 1,000, plus Bright Data's SERP API pricing ($1.50 per 1,000) and its free tier.
4.6 · 99 reviewsMeasured, last 30 days
Requests that returned an answer
The same prompts sent to both APIs in the same hour. One attempt, no retries. See the daily charts
- cloro price
- $1.25–$2.00 per 1,000 (n=10 + AI Overview)
- Bright Data price
- $1.00 to $1.50 per 1,000 requests (SERP API)
On this page
The result in short
Over the last 30 days cloro returned an answer more often than Bright Data on 3 of the 3 engines we measured both on. The widest gap was on ChatGPT: 97.6% against 75.5%.
cloro vs Bright Data
The success rates and response times are our own measurement on the same requests sent to both APIs. A check marks the stronger side of a row. A row with no check is a difference, not a win.
| cloro | Bright Data | |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT success rate, last 30 days | 97.6% (22.1 points higher) | 75.5% |
| ChatGPT mean response time | 49.1 s (58% faster) | 117.7 s |
| Google AI Mode success rate, last 30 days | 99.8% (17.5 points higher) | 82.3% |
| Google AI Mode mean response time | 14.9 s (81% faster) | 78.7 s |
| Gemini success rate, last 30 days | 99.7% (2.4 points higher) | 97.3% |
| Gemini mean response time | 34.1 s (55% faster) | 75.7 s |
| Starting price | $1.25–$2.00 per 1,000 (n=10 + AI Overview) | $1.00 to $1.50 per 1,000 requests (SERP API) |
| Key advantage | Purpose-built for AI engines, citations parsed by default | Massive proxy network, no AIO parsing — bring your own |
| AI Overview Scraping | Native support with parsed citations and sources | Limited support, requires custom implementation |
| Setup Time | 5 minutes self-service | 3-5 business days with approval |
| Proxy Network Size | Optimized for AI engines (ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Mode, Bing AI Mode) | 72M+ residential IPs in 195+ countries |
| API Design | Modern REST API | Complex enterprise APIs |
| Geolocation Support | Comprehensive coverage for all major markets | 195+ countries |
| LLM Visibility Tracking | Built-in ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Mode, Bing AI Mode monitoring | Not available |
| Pricing Model | Monthly credit-based plans, transparent pricing | Pay-as-you-go at $1.50 per 1,000, or plans from $499/month |
| Developer Experience | Self-service, instant API key, comprehensive docs | Sales process, approval required, account management |
Why teams switch from Bright Data
- 01
The parser is yours to maintain
Bright Data returns the raw response and leaves the structure to you. Citations, sources, and positions in a ChatGPT or Gemini answer come from a parser you write, then rewrite whenever an engine changes its markup. cloro ships those fields already parsed, so engine changes are ours to absorb.
- 02
Days to get started
Complex setup process with approval workflows, KYC requirements, and sales calls. Most teams wait 3-5 business days just to get API access. cloro is self-serve: sign up, get a key, first call in 5 minutes, so you can start pulling real data the same day instead of losing most of a week to approval.
- 03
Not optimized for AI platforms
72M+ IPs built for traditional web scraping, not AI engines. AI platforms require specialized infrastructure that proxy networks can't match. cloro runs that infrastructure for ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode, and Bing AI Mode, so calls to those engines succeed instead of getting blocked by infrastructure built for a different job.
Bright Data, often typed as one word (brightdata), is a proxy network with a SERP-data product layered on top. The proxy stack (72M+ residential IPs, mobile carrier IPs, and ISP IPs across 195+ countries) is the actual product, and the SERP API is a convenience wrapper over that infrastructure. That structure is exactly right when you need proxies, and overkill when all you need is parsed Google SERPs.
So if you’re shopping for a Bright Data alternative (or a brightdata alternative, the same question with a different spelling), the real fork is whether you need raw proxies or a parsed SERP API. Most teams searching for Bright Data alternatives in 2026 fall into one of two camps: they want cheaper proxy infrastructure, or they never wanted to manage proxies and parsers for scraping at all and want structured Google SERP data (organic, ads, AI Overview, People Also Ask), or AI chat answers from ChatGPT and Gemini with their citations, returned as clean JSON. We tested five alternatives that cover both camps.
The 5 best Bright Data alternatives at a glance
| Tool | Model | Entry price | Google SERP rate (~1k) | AI Overview parsed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| cloro | Parsed AI-native SERP API | $30/mo (free tier: 500 credits/mo) | $1.25 to $2.00 /1k from Hobby (n=10 + AIO, async) | ✅ deep, +2 credits |
| Bright Data | Proxy + SERP layer | PAYG $1.50 /1k; plans from $499/mo (5,000 free a month) | $1.00 to $1.50 /1k | ⚠️ via Web Unlocker, DIY parse |
| Oxylabs | Proxy + SERP Scraper API | $30/mo ($5 free credits) | $0.90 to $1.35 /1k (Google, JS) | ⚠️ parsed SERP, limited AIO |
| ScraperAPI | Credit-based scraper | $49/mo (7-day trial, 5,000 credits) | 25 credits/call ($2.30 to $12.25 /1k Google) | ❌ no AIO |
| Decodo (ex-Smartproxy) | Budget proxy + SERP API | from ~$0.32 /1k | $0.32–$0.95 /1k | ❌ no AIO |
| Apify | Actor marketplace | $19/mo + usage ($5 free a month) | $1.80 to $2.50 /1k pages | ✅ paid add-on |
The alternatives split on two axes that matter for a Bright Data replacement: whether you get parsed SERP JSON or raw access you parse yourself, and whether onboarding is self-serve or an enterprise sales motion. Bright Data sits at the raw-access, sales-led end of both. Every alternative below moves you toward one or the other. Both axes cost engineering time, not invoice lines.
cloro vs Bright Data, measured
The success rates on this page are our own measurement. Each prompt goes to cloro and to Bright Data in the same hour, one attempt each with no retries: more than 12,500 prompts per engine over the last 30 days.
ChatGPT success rate
- 97.6%
- cloro
- 75.5%
- Bright Data
ChatGPT latency
- 49.1 s
- cloro
- 117.7 s
- Bright Data
Google AI Mode success rate
- 99.8%
- cloro
- 82.3%
- Bright Data
Google AI Mode latency
- 14.9 s
- cloro
- 78.7 s
- Bright Data
Gemini success rate
- 99.7%
- cloro
- 97.3%
- Bright Data
Gemini latency
- 34.1 s
- cloro
- 75.7 s
- Bright Data
Success rate is the daily share of requests that returned an answer. Latency is the daily mean time from request to answer. Updated daily.
In our own measurement over the last 30 days, the same prompts went to both APIs. A response time is our stopwatch from request to answer.
- ChatGPT: cloro returned an answer on 97.6% of requests, and Bright Data on 75.5%. Mean response time: cloro 49.1 s and Bright Data 117.7 s.
- Google AI Mode: cloro returned an answer on 99.8% of requests, and Bright Data on 82.3%. Mean response time: cloro 14.9 s and Bright Data 78.7 s.
- Gemini: cloro returned an answer on 99.7% of requests, and Bright Data on 97.3%. Mean response time: cloro 34.1 s and Bright Data 75.7 s.
How we tested, and what these numbers rest on
Comparison pages are easy to write and hard to trust, so here is the basis for every claim above.
The cloro rows are measured. On 2026-08-19 we ran 15 AI-Overview-prone commercial and informational queries through cloro’s Google endpoint. 14 of the 15 returned a fully parsed AI Overview object, carrying the answer text, a markdown rendering, sources, citationPills, relatedLinks and videos, at a mean of 8.5 sources per overview. That run is the evidence behind cloro’s AI Overview column. One implementation detail if you benchmark us yourself: the field populates only when include.aioverview is sent, and without that flag it is absent whether or not Google rendered an overview, which produces a convincing-looking zero.
The Bright Data and other vendor rows come from each vendor’s own documentation and pricing pages, linked inline throughout. We did not run those APIs under our own keys for this comparison. So read a ❌ or ⚠️ as “not documented as a first-class parsed field” rather than as a test we ran and they failed. Where a vendor has shipped something since we last checked, their documentation is the authority and this page is not.
Pricing moves and none of these figures are quotes. List prices change without notice and promotional rates are common, so treat the per-1,000 rates as the shape of the market rather than a number to budget against, and open the linked pricing page before you commit.
We make one of the products in this table. cloro is listed first because this is our site, not because a neutral panel ranked it there. The measurements above are reproducible and the competitor links go to primary sources; use both to discount our framing.
Bright Data alternatives: per-call price, parsing, and total delivered cost
Headline proxy CPMs mislead, because the number that matters is total delivered cost: the per-1,000 rate plus the engineering you spend turning raw access into parsed SERP rows. A $0.32/1,000 proxy that needs a parser you build and maintain is not cheaper than a $2/1,000 API that returns structured JSON if that parser costs you weeks.
| Vendor | Model | Google SERP rate (~1k) | You parse? | AI Overview |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| cloro | Parsed SERP API | $1.25–$2.00 (n=10 + AIO) | No | ✅ default |
| Bright Data | Proxy + SERP layer | $1.00 to $1.50 | Mostly | ⚠️ DIY / Web Unlocker |
| Oxylabs | Proxy + SERP Scraper API | $0.90 to $1.35 (Google, JS) | No | ⚠️ limited |
| ScraperAPI | Credit scraper | $2.30 to $12.25 (25 cr/call) | Partial | ❌ |
| Decodo | Budget proxy + SERP API | $0.32–$0.95 | Yes | ❌ |
| Apify | Actor marketplace | $1.80 to $2.50 /1k pages, +$1.00 to $2.00 AIO | No on Apify’s Google actor | ✅ paid add-on |
Headline takeaways:
- If Bright Data’s price is the problem: cloro costs $1.20 per 1,000 Google searches on its $100 Hobby plan. Bright Data charges $1.50 per 1,000 pay-as-you-go until you commit to its $499 plan, and cloro also parses the AI Overview for 2 more credits.
- Cheapest raw rate: Decodo ($0.32–$0.95/1k) — but you parse the SERP yourself and get no AI Overview field.
- Closest infrastructure swap: Oxylabs, with Bright Data-class proxy scale, self-serve from $30/month.
- Lowest total delivered cost for parsed Google + AI Overview: cloro, because the AI Overview parser, citation extraction, and PAA hydration are already done — nothing to build or maintain.
- Most expensive for Google specifically: ScraperAPI, where 25 credits a call make Google $12.25 per 1,000 on the $49 Hobby plan and $2.30 on its largest plan.
For the price-only view see Cheapest SERP API 2026; for the full managed-API roundup see Best SERP APIs in 2026.
The 5 real Bright Data alternatives, tested
The best Bright Data alternatives are cloro for parsed, AI-native SERP data and AI chat answers from ChatGPT and Gemini, Oxylabs as the closest like-for-like proxy and SERP infrastructure, ScraperAPI as a developer-friendly proxy with structured endpoints, Decodo (formerly Smartproxy) for the cheapest self-serve SERP scraping, and Apify as an actor marketplace for custom scrapers.
01
1. cloro: best for parsed, AI-native SERP data
cloro’s SERP API is the inverse of Bright Data: there is no proxy product to subscribe to and no parser to build. One endpoint family returns parsed JSON for Google Search and News, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, plus ChatGPT, Gemini and Bing AI Mode, with the actual cited source URLs each AI surface used. Where a proxy hands you HTML to parse, cloro returns organic results, ads, AI Overview (with citations), and People Also Ask in a single response.
That coverage matters more now than it used to. Track classic rank and skip AI citations and you miss half the SERP. cloro also fits existing pipelines through n8n, Zapier, LangChain, and MCP. Synchronous calls cover interactive lookups; async/batch with webhook delivery handles large query sets.
In our own measurement over the last 30 days, the same prompts went to both APIs. A response time is our stopwatch from request to answer.
- ChatGPT: cloro returned an answer on 97.6% of requests, and Bright Data on 75.5%. Mean response time: cloro 49.1 s and Bright Data 117.7 s.
- Google AI Mode: cloro returned an answer on 99.8% of requests, and Bright Data on 82.3%. Mean response time: cloro 14.9 s and Bright Data 78.7 s.
- Gemini: cloro returned an answer on 99.7% of requests, and Bright Data on 97.3%. Mean response time: cloro 34.1 s and Bright Data 75.7 s.
cloro’s reliability is checkable. Elmo, a brand-visibility product that runs cloro as one of its providers, queries each provider every six hours and publishes the measured success rate and latency in Elmo’s provider comparison. It tracks Bright Data on the same engines, so you can run the head-to-head yourself. On latency it had cloro ahead on all three in mid-August 2026: about a quarter quicker on Google AI Mode, and returning in roughly a third of the time on ChatGPT. Those are 7-day rolling averages, so read the current figures rather than these. It scores success rate and latency only, not the parsing differences below.
Pricing: Credit-based from $30/month (Lite, 37,500 credits at $0.80 per 1,000 credits), with Hobby at $100/month for 250,000 credits at $0.40 per 1,000 and rates scaling down to $0.31 per 1,000 on the largest self-serve tier and $0.25 on a custom Enterprise contract. A Google call is 3 credits at n=10, +2 with AI Overview — see the comparison card above for the per-1,000-call cost, and the pricing page for full tiers.

Pros
- AI Overview parsed on request for 2 more credits (block text plus cited source URLs).
- One API across Google and every major AI surface.
- Self-serve signup with a free 500-credit trial.
- No proxy or parser to maintain.
Cons
- Focused on search intelligence — it doesn't sell a raw proxy pool or ship vertical Maps/Jobs/e-commerce scrapers the way Bright Data does.
- Newer than the longest-running proxy vendors.
02
2. Oxylabs: closest like-for-like proxy + SERP infrastructure
If what you actually want is a cheaper version of Bright Data’s core offering, Oxylabs is the nearest match: a 100M+ IP residential and datacenter pool with a dedicated SERP Scraper API on top. The key difference is accessibility: Oxylabs is self-serve from $30/month ($1.35 per 1,000 JS-rendered Google results at the entry tier, per Oxylabs’ Web Scraper API pricing), so you skip much of Bright Data’s sales motion while keeping enterprise-grade infrastructure.
In our own measurement over the last 30 days, the same prompts went to each API.
- ChatGPT: Oxylabs returned an answer on 99.0% of requests, while Bright Data returned one on 75.5%. cloro returned an answer on 97.6%. Mean response time: cloro 49.1 s, Bright Data 117.7 s and Oxylabs 93.2 s.
- Google AI Mode: Oxylabs returned an answer on 98.4% of requests, while Bright Data returned one on 82.3%. cloro returned an answer on 99.8%. Mean response time: cloro 14.9 s, Bright Data 78.7 s and Oxylabs 28.6 s.
- Gemini: Oxylabs returned an answer on 99.3% of requests, while Bright Data returned one on 97.3%. cloro returned an answer on 99.7%. Mean response time: cloro 34.1 s, Bright Data 75.7 s and Oxylabs 32.0 s.
Pricing: One subscription covers every Oxylabs product: Starter $30/month, Basic $100, Flexible $500, Enterprise from $2,500. Google results with JS rendering cost $1.35 to $0.90 per 1,000, and $1.00 to $0.50 without it. New accounts get $5 of free credits (Oxylabs Web Scraper API pricing, read on 2026-10-22).

Pros
- Proxy scale in the same league as Bright Data.
- Self-serve entry tier.
- Parses SERP results rather than handing back raw HTML.
Cons
- Still fundamentally proxy-first; AI Overview parsing is limited versus purpose-built SERP APIs.
- Higher tiers move back toward enterprise pricing and contact-sales.
Bright Data vs Oxylabs, measured
ChatGPT success rate
- 97.6%
- cloro
- 75.5%
- Bright Data
- 99.0%
- Oxylabs
ChatGPT latency
- 49.1 s
- cloro
- 117.7 s
- Bright Data
- 93.2 s
- Oxylabs
Google AI Mode success rate
- 99.8%
- cloro
- 82.3%
- Bright Data
- 98.4%
- Oxylabs
Google AI Mode latency
- 14.9 s
- cloro
- 78.7 s
- Bright Data
- 28.6 s
- Oxylabs
Gemini success rate
- 99.7%
- cloro
- 97.3%
- Bright Data
- 99.3%
- Oxylabs
Gemini latency
- 34.1 s
- cloro
- 75.7 s
- Bright Data
- 32.0 s
- Oxylabs
03
3. ScraperAPI: developer-friendly proxy with structured endpoints
ScraperAPI is closer to a developer product than an enterprise proxy: one API key, proxy rotation and retries handled for you, and structured JSON endpoints for popular targets including Google Search. It’s a strong Bright Data alternative for teams that want proxy-backed scraping without the procurement overhead.
The catch is the credit model. Plans are denominated in credits, and difficult targets cost more. Google’s structured-data endpoints bill at 25 credits per request (ScraperAPI’s published pricing). On the $49/month Hobby plan (100,000 credits) that’s about 4,000 Google SERP calls, an effective rate near $12 per 1,000 for Google specifically. There’s no structured AI Overview field.
Pricing: Hobby $49/month (100,000 credits) up to Advanced $1,975/month (21,500,000 credits). A Google call is 25 credits, so Google costs $12.25 to $2.30 per 1,000. A 7-day trial gives 5,000 credits (ScraperAPI pricing, read on 2026-10-22).

Pros
- Self-serve, developer-first, with a 7-day trial of 5,000 credits.
- Structured Google endpoints (organic, ads, PAA, related) out of the box.
Cons
- Credit weighting makes Google SERP calls expensive relative to a flat per-call SERP API.
- No AI Overview parsing.
- Costs vary by target difficulty.
04
4. Decodo (formerly Smartproxy): cheapest self-serve SERP scraping
Decodo is a self-serve proxy network with its own SERP Scraping API, and on raw per-request price it undercuts everyone here: the Core tier starts around $0.32 per 1,000 requests, with higher tiers landing near $0.88–$0.95 per 1,000. If your only goal is “the cheapest way to pull Google results at volume” and you’re comfortable parsing them yourself, Decodo is hard to beat on headline rate.
Pricing: SERP Scraping API from ~$0.32 per 1,000 (Core) up to ~$0.95 per 1,000 on higher tiers (Decodo’s published pricing); 7-day free trial.

Pros
- Lowest per-request SERP price in this comparison.
- Self-serve with a 7-day free trial, and quick to get a first call out of.
Cons
- No structured AI Overview parsing, so SERP-element extraction is on you.
- Smaller ecosystem and documentation than Bright Data or Oxylabs.
05
5. Apify: actor marketplace for custom scrapers
Apify is a different shape again: a marketplace of pre-built “actors” (scrapers) plus the compute to run them. Apify’s own Google Search Results Scraper covers Google results and sells the AI Overview as an add-on, so you can assemble a scraping pipeline without writing everything from scratch. The trade is that anything beyond Apify’s own actors means picking, configuring and maintaining third-party actors.
Pricing: Plans are $0 ($5 of usage a month), $19, $199 and $999 a month, and actors bill against that balance (Apify pricing). Apify’s own Google actor costs $2.50 to $1.80 per 1,000 results pages on the paid plans, plus $2.00 to $1.00 for the AI Overview (actor pricing, read on 2026-10-22).

Pros
- Huge library covers far more than SERPs (any site with an actor).
- Flexible, and cheaper than Bright Data for mixed, occasional scraping.
Cons
- You inherit third-party actor maintenance, and actors break when sites change.
- Cost is composed from platform subscription, compute, proxy, and per-run fees.
- AI Overview is a paid add-on: $1.00 to $3.00 per 1,000 on Apify's own Google actor.
Bright Data pricing in 2026: SERP API plans and free tier
Bright Data’s SERP API bills per successful request. You can pay four ways: a free tier of 5,000 requests a month with no credit card, pay-as-you-go at $1.50 per 1,000 requests, a monthly Scale plan, or an Enterprise contract (Bright Data SERP API pricing, read on 2026-10-22).
| Bright Data SERP API plan | Price a month | Requests included | Rate per 1,000 above the plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free tier | $0 | 5,000 | none |
| Pay as you go | usage only | none | $1.50 |
| Scale | $499 | 380,000 | $1.30 |
| Scale | $999 | 900,000 | $1.10 |
| Scale | $1,999 | 2,000,000 | $1.00 |
| Enterprise | custom | custom | volume discounts |
The included requests work out to $1.31, $1.11 and $1.00 per 1,000. In async mode, Bright Data counts the request you send, not the call that collects the response. Every plan has unlimited concurrency, and Bright Data lists 195 countries with city-level targeting. At the time of reading, Bright Data also matched a first deposit dollar for dollar, up to $500.
These are the SERP API prices only. Bright Data sells its proxy networks and Web Unlocker as separate products, with their own prices, so a “Bright Data pricing” figure you see elsewhere can be for a different product.
Bright Data vs cloro on price per Google search
A cloro Google search is 3 credits on the async API, and the AI Overview adds 2. On cloro’s $1,000 Business plan that is $1.07 per 1,000 searches, or $1.79 with the AI Overview. On Bright Data’s $999 plan, a request is $1.11 per 1,000. cloro also costs less below Bright Data’s first plan: the $100 Hobby plan is $1.20 per 1,000 Google searches, and Bright Data charges $1.50 pay-as-you-go until you commit $499 a month. At $2,000 a month, cloro is $1.02 per 1,000 and Bright Data’s $1,999 plan is $1.00. A sync cloro request adds 2 credits. The free tiers differ more: cloro’s Free plan is 500 credits a month (about 166 Google searches), and Bright Data’s is 5,000 requests. The takeaway: for organic Google results the price per call is close. The difference is the response. cloro returns the AI Overview with its cited sources as parsed fields, and the same API covers ChatGPT, Gemini and AI Mode.
Migrating from Bright Data to cloro
If you’re moving off Bright Data specifically to stop maintaining proxies and parsers, the switch is small:
- Proxy + your parser → one parsed endpoint. Delete the AI Overview detection, PAA hydration, and ad-sitelink parsing you built on top of Bright Data’s raw access. cloro returns those as structured fields.
- Sales-led onboarding → self-serve. No KYC review, MSA, or account-manager ticket. Sign up, get a key, and pull a real parsed Google SERP with the free 500-credit trial.
- Multi-axis bill → per-call credits. There’s no bandwidth ledger, session cost, or geo premium to reconcile, just one credit rate per call.
- Add AI-surface coverage for free. The same integration that reads Google also reads AI Overview, AI Mode, Bing AI Mode, ChatGPT, and Gemini, so AI-citation tracking is one API, not a second vendor.
The field-level version of this is in the migration guide, which maps Bright Data’s dataset job (a URL and nothing else, with snapshot polling) onto cloro’s parameters, with working Python.
What you can’t migrate to cloro: a raw residential/datacenter proxy pool, or scraping of arbitrary non-SERP sites. If that’s your real requirement, keep Bright Data or move to Oxylabs/Decodo, because cloro is a SERP API and not a proxy.
Decision tree: which Bright Data alternative to pick
Need a raw proxy pool, just cheaper or more self-serve than Bright Data?
For enterprise-scale infrastructure, or Decodo for the budget, self-serve tier.
Want proxy-backed scraping with a developer-first API and structured Google endpoints?
Need to scrape many site types, not just SERPs, and don't mind maintaining actors?
Never wanted to manage proxies or parsers, and just need parsed Google SERPs with AI Overview, plus ChatGPT/Gemini citations through one API?
Cheapest possible per-request rate and you'll parse the HTML yourself?
Decodo
Background
What Bright Data is actually built for

Bright Data is one of the largest proxy networks on the planet, and its SERP API rides on that infrastructure. Onboarding reflects the enterprise posture: most teams submit company details and a use case, clear a KYC/compliance review (some plans require corporate registration), talk to sales about volume, and sign an agreement before API access is provisioned. Pay-as-you-go exists at $1.50 per 1,000, and committed plans (from $499/month, per Bright Data’s published SERP pricing) are where the effective rate drops to $1.00. That procurement rigor is part of why regulated enterprises trust Bright Data. For a developer who just wants JSON back, it’s pure friction.
Where the proxy network earns its keep
For the right workload, nothing in this list replaces Bright Data one-for-one:
- Workloads that need a diverse proxy mix (residential, datacenter, mobile, ISP) routed through specific countries or cities.
- Compliance-bound enterprises that need SOC 2 and GDPR documentation tied to proxy provenance.
- Custom infrastructure deals with negotiated SLAs and dedicated account management.
- Brand-protection and market-research crawls where the proxy layer matters as much as the parsing layer.
If your problem is “we need tens of gigabytes of residential bandwidth per day through country-specific IPs,” Bright Data is a category leader and you should keep it.
Where the proxy stack becomes overhead
For a team that only needs parsed Google SERPs, most of that infrastructure is cost you carry without using:
The AI Overview parser is yours to write. Bright Data’s SERP API delivers JSON or HTML, and its pricing page lists no parsed AI Overview field, so AI Overview detection, citation extraction and People Also Ask hydration are code you write and then maintain as Google’s layout shifts.
The bill is multi-axis too: bandwidth per gigabyte, a SERP CPM, session costs on some endpoints, and geo premiums on harder countries. That’s several line items to reconcile every month.
And nothing starts on day one. The enterprise onboarding path runs 3–5 business days for most teams before the first request goes out.
Each alternative below closes that gap from one side or the other: cheaper proxies, or no proxy and no parser at all.
The bottom line
Bright Data is a proxy infrastructure company with a SERP API on the side, and the best Bright Data alternative depends on which half of that you actually need. If you need the proxies, Oxylabs and Decodo are the like-for-like swaps, one at enterprise scale and one at budget. If you need proxy-backed scraping with a friendlier developer experience, ScraperAPI or Apify fit.
Over the last 30 days cloro returned an answer more often than Bright Data on 3 of the 3 engines we measured both on. The widest gap was on ChatGPT: 97.6% against 75.5%.
But if the reason you’re leaving is that you never wanted to run proxies and maintain SERP parsers in the first place, you want a parsed SERP API rather than another proxy. cloro returns organic results, ads, AI Overview with citations, and People Also Ask in one self-serve call, across Google and every major AI surface, with a free 500-credit trial to baseline your own keywords before you commit.
Bright Data offers enterprise features and diverse proxy infrastructure at premium pricing with multi-day procurement. cloro is the inverse trade: a single per-call SERP API with AI Overview, citations, and PAA parsed on one call, at $1.25 to $2.00 per 1,000 from Hobby (n=10 + AIO, async) vs. Bright Data's $1.00 to $1.50 per 1,000. Per-unit cost favors Bright Data; total delivered cost (including the parser you would otherwise build and maintain) typically favors cloro. Switch from Bright Data when developer time matters more than the headline CPM.
Switch from Bright Data to cloroFrequently asked questions
How does cloro's success rate compare with Bright Data's?
In our own measurement over the last 30 days, on the same prompts sent to both APIs, cloro returned an answer more often than Bright Data on ChatGPT (97.6% against 75.5%), Google AI Mode (99.8% against 82.3%) and Gemini (99.7% against 97.3%).
Bright Data vs Oxylabs: which is better at returning AI answers?
In our own measurement over the last 30 days, the same prompts went to each API. On ChatGPT, Oxylabs returned an answer on 99.0% of requests, while Bright Data returned one on 75.5%. cloro returned an answer on 97.6%. Mean response time: cloro 49.1 s, Bright Data 117.7 s and Oxylabs 93.2 s. On Google AI Mode, Oxylabs returned an answer on 98.4% of requests, while Bright Data returned one on 82.3%. cloro returned an answer on 99.8%. Mean response time: cloro 14.9 s, Bright Data 78.7 s and Oxylabs 28.6 s. On Gemini, Oxylabs returned an answer on 99.3% of requests, while Bright Data returned one on 97.3%. cloro returned an answer on 99.7%. Mean response time: cloro 34.1 s, Bright Data 75.7 s and Oxylabs 32.0 s.
Is cloro a complete replacement for Bright Data?
Not for everything Bright Data does. cloro covers AI scraping and SERP monitoring, with ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode, and Bing AI Mode supported natively and their citations parsed for you. It doesn't sell proxies, so if a raw proxy pool is the thing you're replacing, cloro isn't the swap.
How much can I save by switching from Bright Data to cloro?
Most teams save on operational time and parser maintenance, not just unit cost. Bright Data's SERP API charges $1.50 per 1,000 requests pay-as-you-go, down to $1.00 on its $1,999 plan, but doesn't parse AI Overview, citations, or hydrated PAA. You build that. cloro's page-driven Google endpoint runs $1.25 to $2.00 per 1,000 at n=10 with AI Overview included on Hobby ($0.40/1k credits) and as low as $5.75 per 1,000 at n=100 + AIO on a custom Enterprise contract ($0.25/1k credits).
Does cloro offer the same proxy network as Bright Data?
cloro uses an optimized network for AI engines (ChatGPT, Gemini, Google). Bright Data offers 72M+ residential IPs for diverse scraping use cases. If you need AI scraping and monitoring, cloro is purpose-built for it.
Who are Bright Data's main competitors?
For proxy networks with a SERP API on top, Oxylabs is the closest like-for-like and Decodo (formerly Smartproxy) is the budget, self-serve option. ScraperAPI competes on developer-friendly, proxy-backed scraping, and Apify on a marketplace of ready-made scrapers. cloro competes for the teams that only need Google and AI search results: it returns them as parsed JSON, with no proxy pool to run.
Which is better, Bright Data or Oxylabs?
They are close substitutes, and the choice is mostly about access and price. Both sell residential and datacenter proxies with a SERP scraper on top. Oxylabs is self-serve from $30 per month, with Google results at $1.35 to $0.90 per 1,000. Bright Data's SERP API is $1.50 per 1,000 pay-as-you-go, or $499 to $1,999 a month on a plan. Pick Bright Data for the broadest proxy mix under an enterprise contract, and Oxylabs to start faster at a lower entry price.
How much does Bright Data's SERP API cost?
Bright Data's SERP API costs $1.50 per 1,000 requests pay-as-you-go. Monthly plans are $499 for 380,000 requests, $999 for 900,000 and $1,999 for 2,000,000, which is $1.31 to $1.00 per 1,000. The free tier gives 5,000 requests a month, and Bright Data bills only successful requests.
Is Bright Data a legit company?
Yes. Bright Data was founded in 2014 as Luminati Networks and later renamed, and it says it serves more than 50,000 organizations (Bright Data about page). It has run a KYC (know-your-customer) check on new users since 2015 and states that it complies with GDPR and CCPA. Expect that review before you get residential proxy access.
Is there a free Bright Data alternative?
Bright Data's SERP API has its own free tier: 5,000 requests a month with no credit card. Residential proxy access still goes through a KYC review. cloro gives you free credits to test the SERP API immediately, with no sales call or approval, so you can pull real parsed Google SERPs (organic, ads, AI Overview, PAA) before you pay. Vendors like ScraperAPI offer small free trials too, but those put you on a proxy/scraper product to evaluate rather than a single managed SERP API with AI Overview in the quoted price.
What's the best Bright Data alternative for proxies?
If you genuinely need a raw residential or datacenter proxy pool, Oxylabs is the closest like-for-like and Smartproxy (now Decodo) is the lighter, self-serve option. Both are proxy-first products with a SERP scraper API attached. If what you actually need is structured Google SERP data with AI Overview in one managed response rather than IPs to manage, that's cloro's job, not a proxy's.
What's the cheapest Bright Data alternative?
On raw proxy CPM, Smartproxy and ScraperAPI undercut Bright Data's enterprise minimums. But 'cheapest' depends on total delivered cost: Bright Data's SERP API runs $1.00 per 1,000 at volume and $1.50 pay-as-you-go (plans start at $499/month). cloro's parsed Google endpoint is $1.25 to $2.00 per 1,000 at n=10 with AI Overview included, self-serve, and no proxy to manage. See our cheapest SERP API breakdown for the full cost picture.
Related comparisons
Each page maps cloro's SERP API against one alternative on pricing, AI Overview coverage, and developer experience.
- Ahrefs API alternatives
- Apify alternatives
- Brave Search API alternatives
- DataForSEO alternatives
- Exa alternatives
- Firecrawl alternatives
- Otterly AI alternatives
- Oxylabs alternatives
- Peec AI alternatives
- Perplexity API alternatives
- ScrapeDO alternatives
- ScraperAPI alternatives
- ScrapingBee alternatives
- SearchApi alternatives
- Semrush API alternatives
- SerpAPI alternatives
- Serper alternatives
- Tavily alternatives
- All comparisons